Yesterday, my Seniors turned int their stop motion animations, and we watched them as a class. I just have to say that I love watching student films, no matter how choppy or crazy they may be! Student work like this always amazes me because it shows what great minds these student have.
If I had my way, I wouldn’t worry about grading a project like this at all. In my eyes, just the fact that they went through the process of making the movie based on a classic story from the Decameron shows that they learned plenty. However, today’s students expect a grade for their work and so do parents, administrators, and the state. Teacher have to show that the student learned something by the means of points in a gradebook.
I am not a fan of huge rubrics. Notice that I did not say “I am not a huge fan of rubrics.” It is the other way around for a purpose! I think that the more simple a rubric is, the better off students are, especially when creating a project like a video. The reason for this is that a rubric with 15 different points of achievement may limit the creativity of the student. The whole point of this project is to stretch a student’s thinking, and in order for this to happen, the student has to have some room to think.
Here’s my rubric for this project:
3 points – Video/Story
3 points – Music/Sound Effects
3 points – Attribution
That’s it. That is what I gave to the students as a guide for creating their video. There was another grade early in the project for creating a storyboard, but for the actual video, this is what they got.
I think it worked quite well.
Now I know that there are some out there who are saying, “But what about the standards? The rubric should reflect the state standards and show that the students achieved something in the course of the project.” I am betting that if you asked my students, most of them would be able to recite the common core standard that the worked toward achieving during the project. For this project, the standard was the main goal:
RL.11-12.5: Analyze how an author’s choices concerning how to structure specific parts of a text (e.g., the choice of where to begin or end a story, the choice to provide a comedic or tragic resolution) contribute to its overall structure and meaning as well as its aesthetic impact.
Not only did students learn how an author’s choices make a piece of writing a piece of art, they examined the choices, made their own choices, and made a piece of art their own. They actually became the artist. There is no better way to learn a concept than to practice it.
If you haven’t figured it out already, the whole point of this post is not to trash on rubrics. I know that students need to first know what is expected, and secondly, we have to show that students are learning something. That is the reality of working in education. However, it doesn’t have to be painful. When I see a rubric with 15 different points on it, I feel sorry for both the student and the teacher. Both are going through a lot more headache than necessary for the sake of learning.
Read Full Post »